All Sex Toys
Best Sellers
Vibrators
Dildos
Anal
Male Toys
New Sex Toys
All Vibrators
Anal Vibrators
Clitoral Vibrators
Clitoral Suction Vibrators
Dual Vibrators
Rabbit Vibrators
Massage Wand Vibrators
Egg & Bullet Vibrators
G-Spot Vibrators
App & Remote Controlled Vibrators
Couple's Vibrators
Rose Toys
Lovense
Womanizer
New Vibrators
All Dildos
Anal Dildos
Bendable Dildos
Curved Dildos
Dildo Accessories
Double Dildos
Ejaculating Dildos
Fantasy Dildos
Fisting & Fingering Dildos
G-Spot Dildos
Glass Dildos
Large Dildos
Metal Dildos
Porn Star Dildos
Realistic Dildos
Silicone Dildos
Strap-On Dildos
Suction Cup Dildos
Thrusting Dildos
Vac-U-Lock Dildos
Vibrating Dildos
New Dildos
All Anal
Anal Beads
Anal Plugs
Anal Probes
Anal Dildos
Douches & Enemas
Glass Anal Toys
Inflatable Anal Toys
Multi-Functional Anal Toys
Prostate Stimulators
Suction Cup Anal Toys
Variety Packs & Anal Sets
Vibrating Anal Toys
Water Resistant Anal Toys
New Anal
All Male Toys
Masturbators
Cock Rings
Blow Job Toys
Prostate Massagers
Penis Extenders & Sleeves
Realistic Male Toys
Sex Dolls
Male Vibrators
Penis Pumps
Pocket Pussies
Packers
New Male Toys
All Lingerie
Bras & Bra Sets
Bodysuits & Teddies
Babydolls & Chemises
Bustiers & Corsets
Body Stockings & Hosiery
Panties & Thongs
Fantasy & Role Play
Nipple Tassels & Pasties
Body Adornment
Leather & Latex
Fetish Clothing
Men's Underwear
Sexy Clothing
Rompers
Sleepwear
Robes
Bridal Lingerie
One Size Lingerie
Plus Size
Gloves
Strap Ons
Playboy
New Lingerie
All Bondage & Fetish
BDSM Apparel
Leather Apparel
Handcuffs & Restraints
Sensation Play
Nipple & Clitoral Toys
Spankers & Ticklers
BDSM for Beginners
Electro-Stimulators
Sex Swings & Machines
Sex Pillows & Position Enhancers
Sex Furniture
Fetish Bedding
All Lubes & Essentials
Lubes
Bumpers
Toy Accessories
Pleasure Enhancers
Kegel Exercisers & Balls
Pussy, Vulva, & Clitoral Pumps
Delay Spray & Cream
Bath & Shower
Sexy Chocolate & Candy
Grooming
Massage Oils & Creams
Personal Hygiene
Scented Candles & Oils
Sensual Variety Packs
All Gifts & Games
Blow Up Dolls
Books
Gag Gifts
Adult Games
Romance Starters
Gift Sets
Novelty Candy
Massage Oils & Creams
Scented Candles & Oils
Sensual Variety Packs
Special Occasions
Your Cart
Complete the Experience
Fisting Lubes
Extra-thick formulas hold up through long, slow sessions without thinning out, including a powder you mix with water to the consistency you want. Most are water-based for easy cleanup, and they pair naturally with fisting dildos. For everyday anal play, see anal lubes.
Sort by:
Loading products...
Loading products...
Fist It Extra Thick Rainbow Water-Based Lubricant
$45.99
Product ID: 9053494214892
Default Variant: 46916360175852
Available: true
Selected Variant:
Selected Available:
Fist It Water Based Lubricant
$19.99
Product ID: 9053494444268
Default Variant: 46916360536300
Available: true
Selected Variant:
Selected Available:
Creature Cocks Fisting Cream
$67.99
Product ID: 9088995459308
Default Variant: 47028483522796
Available: true
Selected Variant:
Selected Available:
Fist It Extra Thick Water Based Lubricant
$19.99
Product ID: 9053492019436
Default Variant: 46916357423340
Available: true
Selected Variant:
Selected Available:
Master Series Fisting Water-Based Lubricant
$36.99
Product ID: 9066523525356
Default Variant: 46949283004652
Available: true
Selected Variant:
Selected Available:
NEWEST ARRIVALS
Fresh Temptations
View All
About Fisting Lubes
Fisting lubes are thicker than a standard formula and built to hold up through a longer session without thinning out. Fist It is the dominant brand here, with Master Series and Creature Cocks rounding out the rest of the lineup.
Thickness Over Everything Else
A thick, long-lasting consistency matters more here than scent, flavor, or any added sensation, this is a purely functional category built around one job.
Powder vs. Ready-to-Use
A couple of these come as a self-mixing powder rather than a pre-made liquid, letting you control the final thickness yourself rather than relying on a fixed formula.
Pairs With Large Dildos Too
Anyone working up in size through Large Dildos or Fisting Dildos benefits from the same thick formula, not just literal fisting.
Lubricants & enhancers
For a Softer, Sweeter Ride
View All
LET'S TALK TOYS & MORE
Curious? We've Got The Buzz
Your Pleasure Guide Starts Here
Learn how to pick your first toy, turn up the heat with a partner, or just make solo time extra fun.
Dive Into the Blog
